Sorry ‘Barbie,’ but Actors in Fantasy Films Rarely Enchant Oscar Voters
25.01.2024 - 17:25
/ variety.com
Steven Gaydos Executive VP of Content With the 2023 Oscar nominations now in hand, it’s clear that Margot Robbie’s exclusion from the best actress race, along with “Barbie” director Greta Gerwig’s director snub, has outraged the blockbuster film’s massive global fanbase. What everyone seems to be forgetting is that when it comes to Oscar love, especially for actors, Oscar voters annually choose spinach over sweets, meat and potatoes over champagne and caviar.
They like their movies serious and meaningful, and their actors tortured by real world woes such as people with a disability, addictions, mental illness and all the oppressions and injustices that our mad mad world has to offer. In almost 100 years of the Oscar awards, fantasy and sci-fi film characters, along with actors in comedies, Westerns and actioners, almost never get any love.
It’s getting a little better, but that’s only after nearly 80 years of snobbery and disdain. In 2010, Britain’s much-respected Guardian newspaper ranked the 25 greatest fantasy sci-fi films of all time.
It’s a terrific list for fans of imaginative storytelling, but likely to be depressing for actors who must accept that no matter how brilliantly and memorably they bring their characters to life, respect in the form of Oscar love for their work is a dead issue. The stark reality is that when it comes to honoring those who’ve brought all sorts of fantastic beings to life, from cowardly lions to mermaids (and mermen) to elves to replicants, Oscar voters’ hearts of stone rule out any chances for statues of gold.
The No. 1 film on the Guardian list, Stanley Kubrick’s “2001: A Space Odyssey,” garnered Stanley Kubrick a director Oscar nomination in 1968, but nothing for the film’s actors.
.