‘Civil War’ Review: Alex Garland’s Journey Through War’s Desolation Loses Its Way – SXSW
15.03.2024 - 09:29
/ deadline.com
Alex Garland‘s latest film, Civil War, from A24 and featuring a star-studded cast including Kirsten Dunst, Cailee Spaeny, Wagner Moura, Stephen McKinley Henderson, Jesse Plemons, and Nick Offerman, aims to hold a mirror up to a society spiraling out amongst civil war. In a time when flipping through the news or scrolling through social media can feel like peering into dystopia, Garland wants to crystallize these anxieties into a narrative form, offering a prophetic vision of America’s future. However, despite its ambitious premise and high-caliber cast, the movie stands as a muddled reflection, ultimately rendering its cautionary tale less impactful than intended.
Civil War opens amidst the mayhem of a divided nation, where the President is poised to address the nation on the American Military’s triumph over the secessionist Western states of California and Texas. Amidst widespread disorder, New York City emerges as a primary battleground, morphed into a militarized zone underscored by a palpable us versus them tension. It is here that Lee (Dunst), an esteemed war photographer, encounters Jesse (Spaeny), an aspiring photographer who admires Lee and yearns to join the ranks of war journalism. Lee, renowned within the war photography community, recognizes the diminishing news value in the prolonged conflict, with the ultimate assignment being an interview with the President in Washington, D.C. – now the epicenter of America’s deadliest conflict.
Driven by the conviction that the story outweighs the danger, Lee, alongside her colleague Joel (Moura) and their mentor Sammy (Henderson) – despite concerns about his age – decide to undertake the journey to the capital. Jesse joins the group, completing the quartet bound for