In a case of the world being a lot smaller than you think, Alex Rodriguez was spotted hanging out with Lindsay Shookus at her birthday party in the Hamptons on Saturday (June 19), according to Page Six. In a brief clip obtained by the publication (CLICK HERE TO WATCH), Alex, 45, is seated right behind the now-41-year-old Lindsay while Josh Beckerman (better known online as the “Foodie Magician”) performed a magic routine for all the gathered guests.